Support Groups: A Scientific Overview of Mechanisms and Benefits
Support groups are a type of therapy where individuals with similar challenges get emotional, informational and practical support. They cover a range of conditions from chronic illness, and bereavement to addiction and mental health conditions. Unlike broader group therapy groups, these groups focus on shared experiences and mutual aid, though provide therapeutic benefits for the patient
The benefits of support groups are numerous and evidence based. Social support, a key part of these support groups, has been shown to buffer stress, improve coping and overall wellbeing. Interestingly, research even suggests that on a biological level individuals with strong social support networks have better immune function and cardiovascular health, likely underpinned by reduced stress and healthier behaviours.
Support groups provide a safe space for people to connect with others who have had similar experiences h, leading to a sense of belonging and fewer feelings of isolation. This is especially important for people with stigmatised conditions or those who feel misunderstood by their families and friends.
The Psychological Underpinnings of Support Group Efficacy
The effectiveness of support groups comes down to several key psychological mechanisms.
- Social comparison. Humans naturally compare their experiences to others. Interpersonal comparisons in a safe space such as support groups can help in several ways:
- Downward social comparison, where individuals observe others coping well with similar challenges, giving a sense of hope and self-confidence.
- Upward social comparison, leading individuals to recognise that others may be experiencing greater challenges than themselves, providing helpful self-perspective.
- Self-disclosure. Individuals can share personal thoughts, experiences and emotions in a safe supportive environment. In support groups:
- This can help individuals reframe negative thoughts, helping improve emotional regulation
- Sharing can help individuals process feelings, reducing emotional distress, leading to gaining of new insights, and decreased anxiety and depression.
Types of Support Groups: Formats and Therapeutic Approaches

Support groups are very different in their structure and approach. Some are led by trained professionals like psychologists or social workers while others are peer led. Professionally-led groups often use CBT or other evidence based therapies and may teach specific coping skills like relaxation techniques or problem solving strategies.
Peer led groups focus on shared experience and mutual support, rather than formal interventions or therapeutic techniques. These support groups are often more informal and provide a space to share your story, offer support and learn from each other. Some support groups are structured around specific activities like creative writing or mindfulness exercises while others are more freeform and discussion based. The format of a group should be tailored to the needs and preferences of its members.
Facilitating Emotional Regulation Through Group Dynamics
Support groups can be really good for improving emotional regulation of its participants, providing group members with new tools, insight, and support to manage and respond to emotions in a healthy and adaptive way. The group setting is a unique place to see and learn from others’ emotional regulation strategies. Learning how others cope with difficult emotions can lead to self-improved coping mechanisms.
Group dynamics also play a big role in emotional regulation. Having supportive and empathetic group members can create a sense of safety and validation which can help members feel more comfortable in expressing themselves. In addition, supporting others can be emotionally rewarding providingsense of purpose and connection, as well as promoting emotional wellbeing and reducing psychological distress.
Cognitive Restructuring and Shared Experiences in Support Groups
Cognitive restructuring is a key component of CBT that involves identifying and challenging negative or unhelpful thoughts and beliefs. Support groups can help with cognitive restructuring by offering a space for individuals to share their thoughts and receive feedback from others. Hearing a range of perspectives can help individuals reframe thought patterns and recognise of maladaptive cognitive processes such as distortions like catastrophising and overgeneralising, helping individuals identify and build healthier emotional responses
Shared experiences also play a big part in cognitive restructuring. When you realise you’re not alone in your struggles you may be more willing to challenge your negative beliefs. And hearing how others have overcome similar challenges can give you hope and new ways of thinking. The group as a whole can be a powerful tool for change.
The Role of Social Support in Mitigating Trauma-Related Symptomatology
For people who have been through trauma, support groups can really help with trauma symptoms like anxiety, depression and PTSD. Trauma can leave you feeling isolated and alone, because you can’t connect with people who haven’t been through something similar. Support groups provide a safe and validating space for trauma survivors to share their story and get support from others who understand what you’re going through, while complementing professional therapeutic techniques and interventions.
Research shows that social support is key to resilience after trauma. Support groups can help trauma survivors to rebuild trust, reduce shame and guilt, and develop coping mechanisms.
Measuring Outcomes: Evidence-Based Efficacy of Support Groups

Support groups have been shown to be effective in numerous research studies. Meta analyses which combine the results of multiple studies have found that support groups reduce symptoms of depression, anxiety and chronic pain. Support groups also improve quality of life, coping skills and social support.
Much of the research on support groups is based on observational studies but there is also growing evidence from randomised controlled trials (RCTs) which are the gold standard in research. These studies have found that support groups are as effective as individual therapy for some conditions. However it’s worth noting that the efficacy of support groups can vary depending on the format, population and outcome measures used.
While the statement mentions RCTs, specific findings from these trials are not detailed. However, RCTs are considered the gold standard in research and have shown that support groups can be as effective as individual therapy for certain conditions.
Navigating Challenges and Ethical Considerations in Support Group Practise
While support groups have many benefits, there are also challenges and ethical considerations to be aware of. One of the biggest is confidentiality. Group members need to feel safe and secure in sharing their experiences and it’s essential to set out clear guidelines around confidentiality from the start.
Another challenge is managing conflict within the group. Disagreements and misunderstandings will happen and it’s important to have a plan in place for resolving conflict in a constructive way. Group facilitators whether professional or peer led need to be skilled in conflict resolution and group dynamics.
Ethical considerations also include making sure the group is accessible to all members, regardless of background or circumstances. This may mean providing accommodations for people with disabilities or running the group in multiple languages.
- Informed Consent: Participants should be fully informed about the group’s goals, rules, and expectations before joining.
- Boundary Issues: Facilitators must maintain professional boundaries and avoid imposing personal values on group members.
- Dangerous Behaviours: Policies should be in place to address dangerous behaviours or threats within the group.
- Leadership and Authority: Facilitators must be aware of their influence and ensure that their authority does not lead to unethical practises.
Support groups are a valuable resource for anyone facing many challenges. By understanding the psychology behind how they work and addressing the challenges we can get the most out of them and promote mental health and wellbeing.
Additional Considerations for Promoting Support Groups
- 12-Step Groups: These can be complementary to recovery and inpatient support groups, offering structured programs for specific issues.
- Addressing Shame and Anxiety: Acknowledge that sharing personal struggles can be intimidating. Emphasise the option to observe without sharing initially, allowing individuals to feel comfortable before participating.
- Setting Expectations: Clearly describe what a support group setup might look like, including frequency, size, and structure, to help newcomers feel more at ease
Support groups are a valuable resource for anyone facing challenges, promoting mental health and well-being through shared experiences. Understanding the psychology behind them and addressing common concerns can enhance their effectiveness. For instance, 12-step groups can complement recovery and inpatient support programs by offering structured guidance for specific issues. However, feelings of shame and anxiety may make participation intimidating. Encouraging individuals to observe before sharing can help them ease into the experience. Additionally, setting clear expectations about group size, frequency, and structure can make newcomers feel more comfortable and supported.
Highlands Recovery recognises the importance of comprehensive support systems in the recovery journey and overall wellbeing. While our main focus is on intensive residential care, we also acknowledge the value of ongoing support and aftercare. Our behavioural medicine approach aims to equip individuals with the tools they need for long term self directed health.
Reviewed by: Dr. Emma Bardsley

Dr Emma Bardsley is a neuroscientist with a PhD from Oxford and a post doctorate from Auckland University, along with an undergraduate degree in Pharmacology from King’s College London. She has lectured extensively on neuroscience, physiology, and pharmacological interventions, bridging foundational research and its clinical applications. With a strong record of publications in high-impact journals and extensive experience in scientific writing, editing, and peer review, she excels at translating complex research into practical insights. Based in New Zealand and collaborating internationally, Emma is dedicated to advancing understanding and treatment in the fields of trauma, addiction, and recovery.
References
Schnittker, J. (2010). Chronic illness and self-rated health in late life. Journal of Health and Social Behavior, 51(4), 393–409. Retrieved from https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/0022146510383498
Taylor, F. W. (1954). The principles of scientific management. Human Relations, 7(2), 125–144. Retrieved from https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/001872675400700202
Derlaga, V. J., & Berg, J. H. (Eds.). (1987). Self-disclosure: Theory, research, and therapy. Retrieved from https://www.researchgate.net/publication/314119563_Self-Disclosure
Gross, J. J. (2015). Emotion regulation: Current status and future prospects. Retrieved from http://www.johnnietfeld.com/uploads/2/2/6/0/22606800/gross_2015.pdf
Pennebaker, J. W., & Francis, M. E. (2000). Cognitive, emotional, and language processes in disclosure. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 68(5), 748–757. Retrieved from https://psycnet.apa.org/doiLanding?doi=10.1037%2F0022-006X.68.5.748
Wang, Y., et al. (2022). Psychological resilience and COVID-19 anxiety in frontline nurses. PLOS ONE, 17(1), e0262249. Retrieved from https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0262249